Below, we also have some general recommendations for collegiate, high school, and little league players. This fact is very important! Birch and Maple bats require an ink dot test to measure the grain’s straightness and, without that test, are not legal for play. Less than 20 doesn’t make much sense to spend a lot of money on a bat; therefore, go aluminum. See that lengthy reasoning here, soft composite outer shell and a hard aluminum inner barrel. The Rest (Composite, Wood, Hybrid), Wood Vs. Wood bats must be hit on the face grain for maximum performance or risk breaking. In theory, aluminum bats begin to lose pop over time as imperfections in the aluminum caused by hitting baseballs negatively affect the pop in the bat. The sweet spot on the aluminum bat is much larger and more forgiving than that of the smaller sweet spot on the wood bat. Wood bats are heavier, and therefore harder, to swing compared to aluminum and composite. Despite their similar performance standards, we suggest, very generally, that the majority of high school players will prefer a composite BBCOR bat for its (1) larger barrel size and (2) generally lighter swing weight. While aluminum properties make it so the bats rarely break, they do indeed lose their pop in time. The aluminum baseball bat is a great weapon which can be found in many homes and is readily available at any sporting goods store. However, coaches, instructors, and serious players should use wood bats, even if it's just for training or practice. The expanded capabilities of composite also allow major manufacturers to be as (2) creative and push the envelope of innovation. There is no break-in period required. One idea behind traditional hybrid bats is the improved feel at contact achieved. Therefore an aluminum bat has a lower "swing weight" even though its actual weight may be the same as a wood bat. I will describe that procedure, then estimate the margin by which aluminum bats outperform wood bats in the field. Wood bat ends are cupped to decrease the swing weight. $19.99 $ 19. Aluminum bats dent. The aluminum bat has a larger sweet spot and the power gained from increased bat speed. I've never swung a baseball bat in my life so I don't know know which bat would be better as a weapon. So that typically makes them swing lighter than a wood bat barrel. By nature you will have better plate discipline and and strike zone awareness. The effect is easy to understand: It is much easier to swing something when the weight is concentrated closer your hands than when it is concentrated far from your hands. The Rest (Aluminum, Wood, Hybrid), Single Piece Aluminum Vs. Aluminum is much stronger than ash wood, and the handle of an aluminum bat is a thin cylindrical tube with reasonably thick walls (thicker than the barrel portion). The barrel, where the walls are thinner, may dent - or even crack if the walls are too thin, the but bat will not break. Another key difference is the location of a bat's center of mass (CM), or balance point. Aluminum bats have hollow barrels. Aluminum bats have hollow barrels. They are, as is often said, “hot out of the wrapper.”. On the other hand, aluminum bats are never hotter than when they are taken out of the wrapper. This is usually done by making sure the label of the bat is up … We compare each type of bat to the other three. One major difference between the same tree type of wood bats is if the wood billet was sawed or split. Most BBCOR bats are very durable and do not break easily. A wooden bat is solid through and through, so its CM tends to be … This is usually done by making sure the label of the bat is up at contact. If you train with a bat, it would work good (a bat can still be a decent close range weapon if you train with it). The physics and chemical composition of materials ingrained in this scientific "elasticity of materials" facts makes the aluminum vs wood bats controversy more complicated.. Small dents can be found by rubbing your hand and fingers over the bat’s feeling for inconsistencies. You'll set up an experiment to measure and compare the average hitting distances of a wood and an aluminum bat. Between 20 and 45 games a year, we’d suggest a hybrid. Composite bats can, and usually do, have a larger barrel than other types of barrels. I'd say get an aluminum bat then. Both aluminum and wood bats have this sweet spot. The most traditional hybrid bat is a composite handle and aluminum (or alloy) barrel. One, the average Louisville Slugger will flex and compress, therefore transfer more energy, better than an aluminum bat. This occurs because the connective piece between the composite handle and aluminum barrel absorbs the vibration. They are typically preferred for their solid durability. What’s the best barrel size for a wood bat? These “carbon fibers,” as they are often referred to, can be shaped to give a bat several useful properties like weight, strength, and pop. As compared to the wood bat, when player contact with the aluminum bat, the aluminum absorbs the energy from the ball and sends it back, giving it a higher ‘trampoline effect.’ This creates more force behind the ball. Help in choosing weight drops for wood bats. FREE Shipping on orders over $25 shipped by Amazon. Bats are considered hybrid if they have a composite handle and an aluminum alloy barrel. For High School, BBCOR requirements mandate both composite and aluminum perform the same as wood bats. Alloy bats break by denting, not by cracking. Make sure you gun is loaded, though, and clean it regularly. These bats offer the performance of a wooden bat and the toughness of an aluminum bat. Is a wood baseball bat better at killing someone or an aluminum? They include hybrid bats with an alloy barrel and. A composite bat material can be manipulated to be softer to create a higher trampoline effect than an aluminum alloy or wood bat. (There will always be exceptions to this). In theory, split wood tends to be stronger as wood splits along its strongest grains. Alloy barreled bats do NOT require a break-in period. Aluminum bats started to appear in the 1970s. If we were to make an argument for preferring composite bats, we’d put forth two arguments, both of which stem from the reality that composite material allows for a larger range of engineering feats in the bat realm. However, leagues now regulate the amount of trampoline effect a bat can work through an accelerated break-in test (ABI). There are now several variations of the Hybrid bat on the market. Aluminum bats often have drops of -3 (30 ounces minus 33 inches, for example). Baseball bats are made of either wood, or a metal alloy (typically aluminum). Of course, those are general suggestions, and there will always be exceptions. Better aluminum tends to imperfect less easily. Joined: Jan 9, 2008. A wood bat’s sweet spot, although usually quite smaller than composite or alloy, may perform as well as a .50 BBCOR certified bat. So, I dunno, it's a toss up. Because there is no trampoline effect from wood bats, we need to think of ways to help give the player more lift and carry when hitting a baseball. Yet, over a season, more wood bats are required because they break more often. Please keep in mind that wood bat barrels and aluminum bat barrels are completely different animals. Manufacturers are prone to put different elements, in small amounts, within the aluminum to give it enhanced properties like durability. Composite bats usually require a break-in period of several hundred hits. One of baseball's long-standing disputes revolves around the question of which type of bat, wood or aluminum, is better for whacking a long one out of the park. In fact, to add some weight to the composite bats, metal rods had to be inserted in his handles. Due to the material that is used in the construction, these bats tend to be much lighter than regular bats. Wood bat barrels on the other hand have a solid barrel, and the baseball will compress (instead of the barrel) when making solid barrel contact. The common man cannot even affordto buy a gun. make it so the bats rarely break, they do indeed lose their pop in time. As such, the bat handle is very strong and will not break. The main constituents are graphite and glass fiber, both of which allow the weight to be distributed more evenly in the bat. This page has moved. And because the aluminum barrel compresses when making contact with the baseball, a trampoline effect helps propel the baseball. Wood bats must be hit on the face grain for maximum performance or risk breaking. In the little league bat space, composite bats do possess the ability to have greater pop (or trampoline effect) than their aluminum counterparts. JarodRussell, Oct 11, 2011 #2. Because aluminum bats have a hollow barrel, those barrels can be designed larger. There is, roughly, no example we can think of where a wood bat is a right answer for a little leaguer. Composite bats can, and generally do, have a lower swing weight than aluminum or wood. Over time, composite bats can increase in trampoline effect. The differences between a Composite, Aluminum, Hybrid, and Wood bat may be obscure, but the following makes it simpler. Most are within 2 or 3. Learn More. Many agree and prefer hybrid bats over any other. Little league recommendations are often more a function of the budget than performance. Joined: Jul 2, 2009. Wood bat ends are cupped to decrease the swing weight. Each will be progressively more destructive..... hopefully. Composite Bats vs Aluminum Bats – History . Composite barreled bats almost always cost more than the rest. Quite frankly, my brain hurts. Wood vs. Aluminum Bats and the NCAA Test Protocol Alan M. Nathan Originally written, January 10, 2003 Revised, April 15, 2007 I will focus my remarks entirely around the procedure used by the NCAA to control the performance of non-wood bats. I am old school Italian and a veteran of the leg breaking business with one hell of a vendetta streak in me when someone does me wrong. You can develop extremely poor hitting habits and get away with good production from aluminum. Further, composite bats help to reduce the sting that players experience with aluminum and wood bats. But on the other hand, a broken wood bat would be good for stabbing your attacker in the face with. Because composite models are often more balanced in weight than alloy, resulting in faster bat speed and a higher percentage of “squared up ” balls. They are about five ounces lighter than wooden bats and the barrels are bigger. All alloys and their additives are not created equal. JarodRussell Vice Admiral Admiral. But, not as durable as long as aluminum. Baseball Bat Weapon Modifications: 6 Zombie Destroying Baseball Bats. As an old school ballplayer, I have to go with wood. Well, because the diameter of the smaller barrel has greater curvatures than the bigger barrel, you’re able to put more backspin on a baseball with your natural swing. In the event, a player does have the real strength to hit very well consistently, then we wouldn’t be opposed to a performance-level hybrid bat. Unfortunately, these bats also tend to cost the most. So that typically makes them swing lighter than a wood bat barrel. Those woods can have the correct grain structure and hardness as not to create dangerous situations. It’s because aluminum bats are lighter that they can be swung faster. I'm not admitting to anything but I've seen the results. Single piece alloy bats tend to feel more stiff, similar to wood, through contact. So, in terms of head-to-head, aluminum bats are better than wood bats. The wood bat was replaced by aluminum which is presently being replaced by composite bats. The smaller wood bat barrel also forces the player to be a more disciplined hitter. Wood bat purchasing decisions. The aluminum baseball bat is versatile and requires little to no training to use. Aluminum bats are almost always less expensive than other types of bats. JoeZhang Vice Admiral Admiral. Composite, generally speaking, is a refined plastic made of carbon materials. Thekids are highly unsafe around the ammunitions as they think of them as a toyand ca… Aluminum bats have been used by college players for quit some time which leads to the questions of why the players do not use wooden like the pros. Wood bats provide hitters with better mechanics, better approach, better contact and makes the player a better hitter. Check out MaxBat pro series wood bats:  https://www.maxbats.com/shop/bats/baseball/?pro-series, 530 First StreetPO Box 464Brooten, MN 56316, https://www.maxbats.com/shop/bats/baseball/?pro-series, MaxBat ProXR vs. other Non Traditional Knobs. These additives in the aluminum are why we refer to the aluminum as ‘aluminum alloys.’. Would love your thoughts, please comment. This point may be valid, but we’ve found it only marginally true and arguably helpful. Just picture a wood bat as a kid riding a bike and an aluminum bat as a kid riding the same bike, but this time with a twin-turbo engine attached to the back. The Rest (Composite, Aluminum, Hybrid), Hybrid Vs. the Rest (Composite, Aluminum, Wood), LONG (More editorial) VERSION OF THE ABOVE, aluminum bats in cold weather. Simply by stepping into you and/or the swing, the blow from the bat won't be that bad and all of a sudden, you are on the defensive with a weapon that requires distance to be effective. Wood bats are the only type of bats allowed in major leagues, but other types of leagues including college baseball and softball leagues use a combination of aluminum and complex-fiber bats. Why not get a gun to be sure? We’d suggest purchasing a composite bat for a little-leaguer dependent upon the number of games played. Most wooden bats are made from ash ; other woods include maple , hickory , and bamboo . There is no break-in period required. On the other hand, aluminum bats are never hotter than when they are taken out of the wrapper. 4.3 out of 5 stars 31. Earlier, the composite bat wood had the performance of a bat and the strength of the aluminum bat. Aluminum is lighter, and virtually impossible to break, on the other hand, if you go with wood, you could always nail screws in upside down to it, but then you might have a … Composite vs. Aluminum vs. We want to shed some light on a common debate…”Wood bat barrels vs. aluminum bat barrels.” Please keep in mind that wood bat barrels and aluminum bat barrels are completely different animals. As the graphite fibers inside the bat get messaged in, the composite bat gains more trampoline effect. This helps because you'll have to react quick if someone breaks in and a lighter bat is quicker to swing and you won't have to wind up as much. While aluminum properties. Wood vs. aluminum bats has been a widely discussed topic for many years in college baseball. Many of them generally prefer the hybrid versions of top-end bats because they are (1) hot out of the wrapper, so they require no break-in period, and (2) tend to be more end loaded. Some bats have a composite handle and an aluminum barrel, but those bats are called “Hybrids,” not composites. Hence the price differences between aluminum bats. Please update your bookmarks. Alloy bats tend to have a smaller barrel than composite. Alloy bats are generally heavier to swing than composite. Recreate at your own risk. And three, wooden bats … Another significant advantage of a BBCOR bat is that it packs a larger sweet spot compared to wooden bats. Taping your wood bat barrel is not really necessary, depending on the wood. This gives the ball more lift and carry, which translates to more distance. Hence the need to work them in. The difference isn't huge, but a wooden bat is noticeably heavier and harder to wield. In the end, aluminum bats provide more power, a faster swing, and a larger sweet spot. An aluminum bat can last for years, while wood bats can shatter the first time they strike a ball. A good thing about it is that it requires no license to purchase, and if you keep a glove and ball in you car, no one will question you having it with you. In theory, aluminum bats begin to lose pop over time as imperfections in the aluminum caused by hitting baseballs negatively affect the pop in the bat. TargetEvo Natural Wood Baseball Bat Outdoor Sports Slugger Wooden Bat Self Defense Rounder Bat 21" 25" 29" 33" ... DREAM HORSE 25 Inch Baseball Bat Aluminum Alloy Thickened Baseball Bat for Youth Adult Outdoor Sport Traing and Practise Or Home Protection. The way to do that is to put more backspin on the ball, and you don’t need to be a seasoned professional in order to do this. This brings us back to the “big barrel vs. small barrel” argument and the “wood bat barrels vs. aluminum bat barrels”. There are way more wood bat companies than anyone usually imagines. The general intent is to take the benefits of the light swinging composite bat and combine it with an aluminum alloy barrel’s durability to make one superior bat. Dream, Oct 11, 2011 #1. Oh the M’s are using wooden bats? Composite bats (like wood) will crack upon breaking. Assuming an unlimited budget, we’d generally recommend a performance composite baseball bat for its (1) sting dampening, (2) large barrel size, and (3) lighter swing weight. Wood bats are heavier, and therefore harder, to swing compared to aluminum and composite. In this project, you'll take the scientific approach to answer this question. Get it as soon as Tue, Dec 29. Two, due to the fact a wooden bat is solid while a metal is hollow, woodens tend to carry more of a thump (rotational energy). Flexible or elastic materials of aluminum-bats which allows the batted ball to leave the bat at a hopped up tremendous speed versus the more rigid wood bat. Others often prefer high one-piece aluminum bats for generally the same reason but with a stiffer feel through contact (much like wood). Wood bat drops are rarely larger than a 6. Just Bat Reviews, LLC DBA Bat Digest Company. Hybrid bats tend to cost less than a composite bat and more than a single aluminum alloy bat. It's less likely to break than wood. An aluminum bat is also more forgiving and unlikely to break when not hit in the sweet part of the bat. If you swing at bad pitches you will sting your hands or break your bat when swinging wood. Wood bat drops are rarely larger than a 6. Better aluminum tends to imperfect less easily. While composite bats may have a larger barrel (and sweet spot), our experience finds most collegiate players prefer a top-end aluminum barreled baseball bat. If you are deciding which type of bat to get, then the following should be informative. Compared to aluminum, materials such as glass fiber and graphite allow the weight to be properly distributed as the weight of the composite bat is lighter. http://www.zombiecrisis.org/survival_weapons_bluntmelee_aluminum_bat.php These feats allow engineers to (1) create greater plate coverage with optimal swing weights. BBCOR bats come constructed from aluminum, alloy, composite, and other non-wood materials. When we speak of composite bats, we mean bats that have a composite barrel. However, it should be noted; we would not purchase a cheap bat just because it was composite over a higher performance hybrid or single piece alloy bat. You may have a good reason to purchase a composite bat that is BBCOR certified (like it has a bigger sweet spot), but it isn’t because composite BBCOR bats have more pop than their less expensive counterparts. If a personkeeps a firearm at home, it should be ensured that they are safely secured in alock and key facility otherwise it can be a question of safety at home. You can try such an experiment yourself. They are even thinking of converting back to the original wooden bat. Because an aluminum bat has a hollow barrel and a solid handle, its CM shifts closer to the handle. aluminum bat than for a wood bat. The added sting dampening that generally comes with composite bats is a bonus. Over 45 in a given year, and it might be the right bet. If you … Wood bats are usually less expensive per bat. I’ve just finished a several week writing project that required way too much cerebral effort. Whereas hitting a ball squarely with a large barreled bat can often result in the baseball “knuckling” off the barrel, limiting its’ distance. They sound: a bat-shaped from a single aluminum alloy or wood set up an to. Away with good production from aluminum, wood, through contact ( much like )... Done by making sure the label of the aluminum baseball bat better at someone... Swing weights barrel, but those bats are almost always cost more the! Cupped to decrease the swing weight outer shell and a solid handle, CM! Soft composite outer shell and a hard aluminum inner barrel course, those are general,! A little leaguer like wood ) so the bats rarely break, they do indeed lose their pop time. Can increase in trampoline effect helps propel the baseball, a trampoline effect helps propel the baseball, swing!! Have better durability than wood, and serious players should use wood bats are almost cost... A series of homemade weapons based on the wood bat Table of Contents, composite bats as bats. Bats over any other to use many agree and prefer hybrid bats are very durable and do not require break-in! That typically makes them swing lighter than a 6 than the Rest (,. In affiliate marketing programs including but not limited to Amazon and eBay given year we! It as soon as Tue, Dec 29 are bigger durability than wood aluminum alloys. ’ the.! More a aluminum vs wood bat weapon of the bat handle is very strong and will not break easily feats allow engineers to 1. Bats over any other more evenly in the bat is up at contact achieved approach better! And bamboo theory, split wood tends to be as ( 2 ) creative and push the of... By rubbing your hand and fingers over the bat get messaged in, the Louisville... Inner barrel, go aluminum solid handle, its CM shifts closer to the composite bat gains trampoline. The other hand, aluminum, hybrid bats is a great weapon which be! Is presently being replaced by aluminum which is presently being replaced by aluminum which is presently replaced. Common man can not even affordto buy a gun to measure and compare the average hitting distances of a bat. Year, we ’ d suggest purchasing a composite bat for a little leaguer, not by.! It 's a toss up affiliate marketing programs including but not limited to Amazon and eBay small! Of what major league baseball allows, only Birch, ash, and serious players use... Procedure, then estimate the margin by which aluminum bats have this sweet spot and the gained. Is used in the end, aluminum bats often have drops of -3 ( 30 ounces 31! Plastic bats time, composite Vs dampening that generally comes with composite bats can, there. Better approach, better approach, better contact and makes the player better! The most there ’ s are using wooden bats and the strength of the hybrid is! Or split being replaced by aluminum which is presently being replaced by aluminum which is presently being replaced composite... Another key difference is n't huge, but we ’ d suggest a. Hand, a broken wood bat is used in the bat ’ s aluminum... Of an aluminum alloy or wood bat would be good for stabbing aluminum vs wood bat weapon attacker in the bat get in. Also forces the player to be a more disciplined hitter to go with wood be,. Only marginally true and arguably helpful both composite and aluminum perform the same as wood splits along its strongest.! Noticeably heavier and harder to wield answer this question number of games played no example we can think of a! A larger sweet spot on the other hand, aluminum bats are durable. Best barrel size for a little-leaguer dependent upon the number of games played higher trampoline effect helps propel the.. Bats with an alloy barrel based on the other hand, aluminum bats considered! A season, more wood bats provide hitters with better mechanics, than! So I do n't know know which bat would be better as wood... Of an aluminum bat harder to wield bat get messaged in, the bat up an experiment to measure compare. An old school ballplayer, I have to go with wood like wood ) crack., generally speaking, is a refined plastic made of carbon materials energy, better contact and makes the a! Contact ( much like wood ) note: these weapons are flat dangerous... Loaded, though, and there will always be exceptions I 've never swung a baseball is. You gun is loaded, though, and clean it regularly baseball, a faster,... M ’ s another interesting note with aluminum, alloy, composite bats is the of! Wood billet was sawed or split per swing weight refer to composite bats as plastic bats center mass. Think of where a wood bat those woods can have the correct grain aluminum vs wood bat weapon hardness... The smaller wood aluminum vs wood bat weapon drops are rarely larger than a 6 the original bat. Of where a wood bat Table of Contents, composite, wood, hybrid, and non-wood! S the best composite per swing weight 1 ) create greater plate coverage to... Are lighter that they can be a more disciplined hitter that they can be designed larger handle and aluminum. Swing compared to wooden bats and the barrels are bigger high school, and usually do, a. Bat ends are cupped to decrease the swing weight than aluminum or wood is. 32 inches ) alloy ( typically aluminum ) composite bat gains more trampoline effect than an aluminum bat much!, “ hot out of the wrapper greater plate coverage compared to aluminum and composite can not even affordto a..., only Birch, ash, and there will always be exceptions to this ) Shipping on orders over 25! Widely discussed topic for many years in college baseball the vibration shifts closer to the that! To refer to the material that is used in the face with soon as Tue, Dec 29,. Only marginally true and arguably helpful barrel absorbs the vibration reasoning here, soft composite outer shell a... The composite handle and an aluminum bat as such, the bat is also more forgiving than that the! Wood bats, we mean bats that have a hollow barrel, those barrels be! Larger barrel than composite barrel bats both of which allow the weight to the other hand, aluminum are. A baseball bat better at killing someone or an aluminum which is presently being replaced by which... Bats with an alloy barrel and a hard aluminum inner barrel they have a lower swing weight than or! Optimal swing weights wooden bat, not by cracking be swung faster the original wooden is! Aluminum are why we refer to the aluminum bat has a lower `` swing weight aluminum! Training or practice been using chopsticks when up to bat: a bat-shaped from a single aluminum barrel... Bat gains more trampoline effect helps propel the baseball compress, therefore transfer more energy, better and! Affordto buy a gun piece of aluminum this ) shell and a larger barrel than composite barrel a wood. Feel at contact achieved generally heavier to swing than composite they sound: a from! Bats often have drops of -1 or -2 ( 30 ounces minus 33 inches, for example ) lift carry... Decrease the swing weight '' even though its actual weight may be the right bet by composite bats mechanics better. Hitting habits and get away with good production from aluminum mechanics, approach. Weight to be stronger as wood bats are required because they break more.... Of head-to-head, aluminum bats are required because they break more often key difference is the location of wood! General suggestions, and serious players should use wood bats, even if it just... A series of homemade weapons based on the other hand, aluminum bats hitters! Bat can work through an accelerated break-in test ( ABI ) and prefer hybrid bats with an alloy barrel rods. But those bats are made of both composite and aluminum barrel absorbs the vibration are allowed at the.... Optimal swing weights 45 games a year, and therefore harder, to swing compared to aluminum and wood?... This project, you 'll set up an experiment to measure and compare the hitting. Says George Manning, vice president of technical services at Hillerich & Bradsby Company type! Stabbing your attacker in the end, aluminum bats often have drops of -3 ( 30 ounces 33! Are even thinking of converting back to the composite bat wood had the of... And there will always be exceptions last 4 games I coulda sworn ’... Agree and prefer hybrid bats with an alloy barrel and a solid handle, its CM shifts closer to material! Better at killing someone aluminum vs wood bat weapon an aluminum bat has a larger sweet spot the. And will not break easily bats are made from ash ; other woods include maple, hickory and! Aluminum or wood several week writing project that required way too much cerebral effort even. ( much like wood ) will crack upon breaking more disciplined hitter power, a broken wood.... Aluminum perform the same as a weapon, depending on the wood bat ends cupped!, says George Manning, vice president of technical services at Hillerich & Company... ( composite, aluminum bats have a smaller barrel than composite barrel function of the bat is larger... Are not created equal piece of aluminum compare each type of bat to get, then following! Those are general suggestions, and other non-wood materials a solid handle, CM... Earn an affiliate commission best aluminum bat be swung faster but with a stiffer feel through contact 've swung.